Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Comments

Want to discuss the merits of the PPP Project? Do so here. Do NOT flame others or spam. Comments are moderated anyway.


Just to get things out of the way, here's a glossary of our acronyms:

P = myself
PP = Primary Product (the first proof-of-concept clip)
PPP = Perfect Plot Productions (the end goal, the edited episodes)
PPPP = Pony Plot Perfection Project (the Project as a whole)
PPPPP = Pony Plot Perfection Project Periodical (this blog)
PPPPPP = Pony Plot Perfection Project Planning Process (scheduling, assigning roles, etc.)
PPPPPPP = Perfectly Proud Pony Plot Perfection Project Participant (a member of the PPPP)
PPPPPPPP = Perfectly Proud Pony Plot Perfection Project Participant Pursuit (recruitment)
PPPPPPPPP = Persistently Party Pooping Pony Plot Perfection Project Protest Participant (haters)

46 comments:

  1. A simple question with a simple answer: Why not?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, that's not an answer unless you like being an ass.

      But if you want to play semantics, fine; Why in the world would you want to do this, and who do you think actually wants this to be made besides very strange individuals?

      Delete
    2. How about...

      Editing obscene content into a children's cartoon will damage the brand and the reputation of the producers.

      Delete
  2. A few people have expressed interest already. "Strangeness" is in the eye of the beholder, but I much prefer strange people to boring people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The thing is, who would actually want this to occur besides a few people that strange might not even be a good term for? You say strangeness is variable, and while that's sometimes true, nearly everyone would find this project 'at least' strange.

      I mean, I'm not sure what you're hoping to accomplish with this. Drawing genitals and such on cartoons to do... what exactly? Who would want that besides people who masturbate to such things in their mothers basements? And don't you think this is going to get you (And this fandom) a lot of flak you could easily avoid by just, say, drawing regular porn?

      Delete
    2. It's not a sexual project.

      Delete
    3. I'm not sure at all how you can say a project dedicated to giving cartoon horses genitals is not at all sexual. If it isn't, what the fuck is it then?

      Delete
    4. No. Art is not this. This is the exact opposite of art. It's like calling shit smears on a wall art. You can't justify this with such a meager defense unless you are either insane, or trolling. I'm leaning towards the latter by now.

      Delete
    5. It is certainly art. Whether it is good art depends on the person, and cannot yet be determined, but it fits the definition of art.

      Delete
    6. Not it isn't art, because you are using a work that belongs to someone else, buttmunch.If you could get Hasbro's permission to do this, I would shut my mouth right up, but if you can't you won't do this, unless you wanna get sued, right on the butt.

      Delete
    7. Does being based on an existing work make something not art? What about all the PMVs, fanart, and fan dubs that are already out there?

      Delete
  3. Your project are marvelous :D I hope you can find some artist and begin the PPP project as soon as possible :) the reason why I don't request to take part to this project is that I am very bad in the art of drawing :( but i continue follow your amazing project.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. You can help by recruiting others even if you can't draw.

      Delete
  4. Ridiculous joke, troll. Get better taste.
    Next time why not make the whole episodes of G4 in the G1 style?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not a joke, and not a troll. Sorry, mate.

      Delete
    2. I'm not going to lie here. I have an open mind. I really do. I'm not going to sit here and yell and troll you, because I'm not like that. However, I'll ask a simple question: Why are you doing this?

      Pleade don't answer "Why Not?". That's a childish, immature answer. I want a real reason. Are you doing it to feel more accomplished?
      To "fix" a nonexistant problem?
      To make us look bad?
      I ask you this with an open mind and a closed heart, my friend.

      Bronies are already hated on. Terribly. People tend to troll, hate, spam, and bully us like the Furries are. Maybe a bit less, maybe a bit more. Who am I to judge this? Or you?

      You can do whatever you want. Just keep in mind, people will hate you. They will hate us. People will mock all of us.

      This will drop people's views of "us". It will make the fandom seem like scum. I say to you, friend, what artistic vision does this accomplish?
      What philosophy or theology does this hope to exert?

      Is one not truly free to open his soul to public without his eyes being gauged? The answer is yes. The action of one will cause a chain.

      People are stupid. Minds have slumped to the point of stereotypical classification through unset minds and unsettled souls.

      Please, friend. Consider the worst and not the best, for those who remain hopeful will fall to the despair as the cloud approaches those who wait.

      Please. For one, as a brony. For two, as a friend and humanly brother. And Three, for the good of humanity under the eyes of the fair divine or universe.

      Consider your actions. Thank you for your time, I await your reply.

      Delete
    3. Personally, Barbie doll anatomy just looks weird to me. It's like some sort of uncanny valley thing. Aesthetically, I think that they look better with at least some suggestion of the relevant organs. If you disagree, you're free to not join.

      As far as how people will respond, that's not really something you should concern yourself with. There's nothing wrong with the PPPP, and you shouldn't be seeking the approval of anyone who would demonize the fandom for it.

      Delete
    4. Uhhh, infringment of copyright is wrong by law.Dooming a whole fandom for your "fantasy", or whatever you call it, is ethically wrong.As it is, again, ethically wrong to modify episodes with unsafe content, knowing people below proper age watch the show, and search about it on the internet.
      And that's that...I don't usually agree with common sense, but if you can't give arguments to negate the reasons I gave above, you have to agree that's a stupid pursuit.

      Delete
    5. Very NSFW fanart already exists of the show. The PPP, on the other hand, will be no more "unsafe" than a trip to the zoo.

      I'd love to know what you think is "proper age", seeing as lots of kids have pets, and even, gasp, see HUMAN genitals in the bath.

      Delete
    6. Anon,

      G1 was not a cheap joke. It was my childhood.

      The animation in 'Rescue at Midnight Castle' is gorgeous, realistic, fluid, and suitably horse-like. To emulate such a style would take time, money, and love.

      But, since G1 is nothing but a fucking joke to you and to everyone else these days, it will be posted on Equestria Faily for April Fool's Day.

      I would honestly prefer to see Perfect Pony Pussy or whatever the fuck this shit is, than to see my dear G1 smeared, yet again.

      Fuq u Anon.

      Delete
  5. Yes, but complete episodes is a whole other matter.
    The diference is...in cartoons like my little pony, where there is anthropomorphy, the characters have human-like emotions, actions and sometimes even anatomy.That creates the sexual arousal, and that's why there is cartoon, furry porn and whatever else.

    Our animals don't talk, they don't express like humans do.To be aroused by animals is most usually a disorder.That's why zoosexuals are uncommon.

    Now, if you edit genitals on cartoons, it can and probably would cause sexual arousal on most viewers.Even more when the characters act and sound like women in their twenties.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hay everypony, no reason to be butthurt. I'm not personnaly interested in pony genitals, but I don't think there's anything wrong with this project.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Continue the project if you much need but there no point of putting genitals to a cartoon pony you are creating anti art and don't say it art, this is the most pointless thing that come out in life, now to be fair this may be a homage to old art but in this day of age i don't think so, in this day of age there is no point, come back when you know that you lost your mind on something vulgar.

    ReplyDelete
  8. While I have my doubts about this project, I'm not going to attack your goals.

    My simple question is: Why?
    I'm just not exactly sure what exactly you hope to accomplish by doing this.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Do you have any defense for making people who like MLP look like freaks by association? Or is that the idea of it?

    ReplyDelete
  10. So, once you're done with the ponies, what anatomically incorrect cartoon are you going to fix next?

    ReplyDelete
  11. I would ask you to name a children's cartoon where things are anatomically correct for the whole episode...
    Or I would ask you to name an non-sexual edit of a cartoon where things are anatomically correct for a whole episode.
    The reason you wouldn't be able to name a single example of either is because society doesn't see this concept as normal.
    But you wouldn't understand what normal means... Hell you probably don't understand why people don't see the brony fan base as it is as normal.
    So arguments about normality aren't going to phase you the slightest.
    Sure you could call what this abomination is as art... But you'll never be respected seriously by anyone worth a grain of respect in the art industry in this lifetime.

    Have you ever mentioned this to someone irl?
    What was their reaction?
    Did it hurt when they broke your jaw?

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm twelve and what is this

    ReplyDelete
  13. This doesn't make sense to me at all. What level of autism must one go to to follow through on such a project? It's like adding genitals to the pokemon series. Editing the sprites and such. This is like taking something to the next level...

    ReplyDelete
  14. I can say that this project does interest me somewhat. However, I do hope you realize that people outside this group are going to be looked down upon just as much as people who are within. People who aren't bronies don't tend to differentiate.

    Personally, if I thought this could actually remain down-low and available only to those who actually want it, I would be in complete and total support. However, as it stands, if you do this, word will inevitably get out and cast an awful shadow on the rest of us bronies. You can explain to us all you want that this is not meant to be sexual, and some might even believe it. But you won't convince all the countless other people who would give us grief.

    To sum it up, I think it would be better to not do this, instead of doing it. At least for now.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Your project caught my eye and I must say it is rather intriguing. I do think that some of the above opinions are not valid and I agree, this is a for of art that you are free to explore. Calling this pornographic is like saying any medieval or renaissance art is inherently pornographic due to the nudity of the subject at hand. (For those who would hate on my comparison I am merely responding to the statements above claiming this to be sick and pornographic.)

    My only question is how will you determine the gender of the characters as, not having watched the show in great detail myself, notice only one or two male characters with the rest being female or like young boys. Just mild curiosity on my part.

    I shall follow this project with some interest and wish you the best in your endeavors. Ignore the hate as well, it is what the internet does best.

    -An Anonymous Writer

    ReplyDelete
  16. I wish you all slow, painful deaths.

    ReplyDelete
  17. You can claim this isn't a troll as much as you want and you're only doing this for pseudo-education porpoises, claim that its art etc etc etc. But everyone can see through the ruse, bro.

    In all seriousness if you're doing this just to get a rise out of people and cause a moderate shitstorm, I hope you have some strong sails on your boat. Hell hath no fury like this show's fucked up fanbase.

    If you're doing this for personal reasons, ew. Ew ew ew.
    Also ew.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I assure you that porpoises have nothing to do with this.

      Delete
  18. As if this fandom couldn't sink any lower...

    ReplyDelete
  19. Guys this is an obvious troll, THEIR SUMBOL IS A STEP AWAY FROM A SWATZSTIKA

    ReplyDelete
  20. That depends on how big your steps are. Even then, Eastern religions had the swastika for longer than Hitler.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hold up, dude. If all you want to see is anatomically correct ponies, here: http://rule34.paheal.net/post/list/Friendship_is_magic/1

    Save your energy, man. The internet has already done you this favour.

    ReplyDelete
  22. All the AIDS in the world is too good for you. That is all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure "All the AIDS in the world" would be much different from just "Some of the AIDS in the world". To my knowledge, you either have AIDS or you don't.

      Delete
  23. If you're going to correct their lack of genitals, why not the rest of their anatomy? Would you want to see lifelike horses conversing?

    ReplyDelete
  24. ...
    Just when we thought the ponyfags fandom could not get any worse

    ReplyDelete
  25. You guys are so stupid it makes me sick to be human.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Just give up you fucking furfags, no one wants to be a part of your sick fucking project.

    ReplyDelete